THE FINANCE COMMITTEE WILL MEET ON TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 2000, AT 6:30 P.M., IN THE PERSONNEL CONFERENCE ROOM, HUMAN SERVICES BUILDING, 5303 S. CEDAR, LANSING.
NOTE CHANGE IN TIME AND DATE
Agenda
Call to Order
Approval of the November 8, 2000 Minutes
Additions to the Agenda
Limited Public Comment
1. Treasurer
2. Circuit Court - Resolution to Authorize a Contingency Fund Appropriation for the Circuit Court Family Division to Participate
with Verizon Communications for a Proposal to Provide 30 Cellular Phones
3. Sheriff's Office
4. Commissioner Randy Schafer - Resolution to Adopt a 911 Emergency Telephone Dispatch Services Fund
Allocation Policy
5. Purchasing & Properties - Sale of Kitchen Equipment from the Ingham County
Correctional Facility
6. Human Resources Department - Resolution Authorizing Restructuring of Ingham County
Prosecuting Attorney's Switchboard Operator Position
7. Health Department
a. Memorandum Regarding Countywide Recycling Plan
b. Resolution to Accept Modification to the Ingham County Solid Waste Plan Update Proposed by the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality
c. Resolution to Authorize an Agreement with Smart Corporation
d. Resolution to Authorize a Contract with Children's Choice of Michigan
e. Resolution to Appropriate Funds to Support the Ingham Health Plan's Subsidized Health Insurance Program for Low Wage Paying Firms
f. Resolution to Amend the Project Respect Contract with the City of Lansing
g. Resolution to Authorize an Agreement with Ingham Regional Medical Center for Women's Health Physician Services
8. Controller
a. Third Quarter 2000 Budget Adjustments, Year End Adjustment, and Contingency Fund Update
b. Resolution Authorizing a Reorganization of the Purchasing and Properties Department
c. Resolution to Authorize the Purchase of Computer
Equipment for the Board of Commissioners
Announcements
Public Comment
Adjournment
The County of Ingham will provide necessary reasonable auxiliary aids and services,
such as interpreters for the hearing impaired and audio tapes of printed materials being
considered at the meeting for the visually impaired, for individuals with disabilities at
the meeting upon five (5) working days notice to the County of Ingham. Individuals with
disabilities requiring auxiliary aids or services should contact the County of Ingham in
writing or by calling the following: Ingham County Board of Commissioners, P.O. Box 319,
Mason, MI 48854 Phone: (517) 676-7200. A quorum of the Board of Commissioners may be in
attendance at this meeting.
Return to top of document
The following items have attachments available in the Board of Commissioners Office:
1. Treasurer
3. Sheriff's Office
4. Commissioner Randy Schafer - Resolution to Adopt a 911 Emergency Telephone Dispatch
Services Fund Allocation Policy (attachment)
5. Purchasing & Properties - Sale of Kitchen Equipment from the Ingham County
Correctional Facility- Attachment
7. Health Department
a. Memorandum Regarding Countywide Recycling Plan
b. Resolution to Accept Modification to the Ingham County Solid Waste Plan Update Proposed by the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality
g. Resolution to Authorize an Agreement with Ingham Regional Medical Center for Women's
Health Physician Services
8. Controller
a. Third Quarter 2000 Budget Adjustments, Year End Adjustment, and Contingency Fund Update - Attachment
b. Resolution Authorizing a Reorganization of the Purchasing and Properties Department
(attachment)
FINANCE COMMITTEE
Minutes
Members Present: Mark Grebner, John Czarnecki, Jean McDonald, Randy Schafer
Tom Minter and Wallace Juall
Members Absent: Virgil Bernero
Others Present: Jerry Ambrose, Mary Stid, Bruce Bragg and Harold Hailey
The meeting was called to order by Vice Chairperson Grebner at 6:34 p.m. in the
Personnel Conference Room of the Human Services Building, 5303 South Cedar, Lansing.
Approval of the September 27, October 18 and October 24, 2000 Minutes
The September 27 Minutes were approved as amended. Absent: Comm. Bernero
The October 18 and October 24 Minutes were approved as submitted. Absent: Comm. Bernero
Additions to the Agenda
1b. Resolution Authorizing Improvements in the Holding Cell and Attorney Rooms in the
Ingham County Jail - Attachment - Item pulled from the Agenda.
2c. Resolution Authorizing an Agreement with Ingham Regional Medical Center for Women's
Health Physician Services - Item pulled from the Agenda.
4. Board of Commissioners - Resolution to Authorize the Purchase of Computer Equipment
for the Use of the Commissioner's Office - Item pulled from the Agenda.
Limited Public Comment: None
MOVED BY COMM. MCDONALD, SUPPORTED BY COMM. SCHAFER, TO APPROVE A CONSENT AGENDA FOR
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS:
1. Sheriff's Office
a. Resolution to Accept the 2000 D.A.R.E. Drug Abuse Resistance Education Grant
2. Health Department
b. Resolution to Authorize a 0-3 Secondary Prevention Grant with the Family Independence Agency for 2000-2001
e. Resolution to Amend the Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Grant Agreement
MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. Absent: Comm. Bernero
MOVED BY COMM. MCDONALD, SUPPORTED BY COMM. SCHAFER, TO APPROVE THE ITEMS ON THE
CONSENT AGENDA. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. Absent: Comm. Bernero
2. Health Department
a. Resolution Authorizing Entering Into a Contract with Patterson Dental Supply Inc.,
and Accubite Dental Supply for the Purchase of Dental Clinic Equipment
In response to Comm. Schafer, the Committee consented to amend the second WHEREAS paragraph as follows:
WHEREAS, the Task Force has identified that Medicaid insured children in the Ingham
County area have difficulty finding dentists willing to serve them; and
MOVED BY COMM. MCDONALD, SUPPORTED BY COMM. CZARNECKI, TO APPROVE THE RESOLUTION
AUTHORIZING ENTERING INTO A CONTRACT WITH PATTERSON DENTAL SUPPLY INC., AND ACCUBITE
DENTAL SUPPLY FOR THE PURCHASE OF DENTAL CLINIC EQUIPMENT AS AMENDED. MOTION CARRIED
UNANIMOUSLY. Absent: Comm. Bernero
In response to Comm. Czarnecki, Mr. Bragg explained the Health Department does not encourage people from other counties to use Ingham County's services. This service is intended to be fully supported by grant funds and Medicaid. It is our intent not to use any County general funds. Comm. Czarncki stated we need to make sure Clinton and Eaton counties step up to the table and accept responsibility for their residents.
d. Resolution to Authorize Administrative Services and Medical Services Support Agreements with the Ingham Health Plan Corporation
MOVED BY COMM. SCHAFER, SUPPORTED BY COMM. JUALL, TO APPROVE THE RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AND MEDICAL SERVICES SUPPORT AGREEMENTS WITH THE INGHAM HEALTH PLAN CORPORATION. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. Absent: Comm. Bernero
3. Human Resources
a. Resolution Approving a Collective Bargaining Agreement Between the County of Ingham, Ingham County Probate Court, Thirtieth Judicial Circuit Court, 55thJudicial District Court, Ingham County Prosecuting Attorney, Ingham County Clerk, Ingham County Register of Deeds, Ingham County Treasurer, Ingham County Drain Commissioner and Ingham County Sheriff with the Technical, Office, Para-Professional and Service Classifications of the United Automobile
Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW) - Local 2256
In response to Comm. Schafer, Mr. Hailey explained the departments named in the
Resolution are considered to be employers. The employer will pick up 3.2% of the
retirement cost. Mr. Hailey stated the County will see further cost savings in the second
year as the wage scale will not be increased. He also stated he would provide Comm.
Schafer with a copy of a contract.
Comm. Minter explained his concern he raised in the Administrative Services/Personnel
Committee meeting tonight regardind an element of the proposed action. The element of
concern regards the statement "HR Director, upon approval by the Department Head, may
approve initial compensation of new hires through Step 4;" Some elements of a
proposed action may not be readily known to the Committee until it comes before this
Committee. Comm. Minter stated he believes it is appropriate that all elements of the
initial bargaining position advanced by the County be made known to the Commissioners in
case they have some philosophical differences with the approach. Comm. Minter stated he is
only concerned with the process, not the merits.
In response to Comm. Czarnecki, Mr. Ambrose explained the issue of providing a defined
contribution plan to all new hires has not been successfully negotiated with the
collective
2
bargaining units. He requested Mr. Ambrose or Mr. Hailey draft a resolution declaring
it to be County policy that future contracts will provide a defined contribution plan.
Comm. Czarneckis stated he would bring this resolution to the Board as a personal.
Comm. McDonald stated the Administrative Services/Personnel Committee has discussed the
issue of economic parameters with Mr. Hailey regarding bargaining matters. The
Administrative Services/Personnel Committee has informed Mr. Hailey that when new issues
come up during the bargaining process, he is to submit a memorandum to the Committee
notifying them of the issues.
Mr. Hailey stated the Human Resources Department did propose a defined contribution
plan to the bargaiing units during the recent negotiations. The proposal was for new
hires. However, the proposal was not accepted. The current members wanted to know the
potential impact this would have on existing members.
Comm. Czarnecki stated the Board needs to discuss this important issue. Vice
Chairperson Grebner stated this matter will be discussed in early January. This matter
will be explored thoroughly before it is presented to the Board.
MOVED BY COMM. MCDONALD, SUPPORTED BY COMM. CZARNECKI, TO APPROVE THE RESOLUTION
APPROVING A COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE COUNTY OF I NGHAM, INGHAM COUNTY
PROBATE COURT, THIRTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURT, 55TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT, INGHAM
COUNTY PROSECUTING ATTORNEY, INGHAM COUNTY CLERK, INGHAM COUNTY REGISTER OF DEEDS, INGHAM
COUNTY TREASURER, INGHAM COUNTY DRAIN COMMISSIONER AND INGHAM COUNTY SHERIFF WITH THE
TECHNICAL OFFICE, PARA-PROFESSIONAL AND SERVICE CLASSIFICATIONS OF THE UNITED AUTOMOBILE
AEROSPACE AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT WORKERS OF AMERICA (UAW) - LOCAL 2256. MOTION CARRIED
UNANIMOUSLY. Absent: Comm. Bernero
b. Resolution Approving the FOP/ Law Enforcement Collective Bargaining Agreement
MOVED BY COMM. MINTER, SUPPORTED BY COMM. MCDONALD, TO APPROVE THE RESOLUTION APPROVING
THE FOP/LAW ENFORCEMENT COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
Absent: Comm. Bernero
Comm. Schafer informed the Committee that he was endorsed by the FOP. He did
not receive funding from the FOP.
5. Controller
a. Economic Development Corporation - Tax Abatement Notifications - attachment
Mr. Ambrose stated that when the Board receives notification regarding any type of tax
abatement, the notification will be forwarded to the Economic Development Director.
b. Budget Update
Mr. Ambrose explained he hopes letters of understanding from all of the unions will be brought before the Board before the end of the year. The letters would slightly modify our health
3
insurance benefits. The Health Coalition has been working to develop alternatives to
the 44% proposed increase in premiums. When the discussions are complete, the increase
will be approximately 20%. Mr. Ambrose explained some of the alternatives.
6. Board Referral - Letter from the City of East Lansing Announcing the Approval of a
Brownfield Plan
The Board Referral was received and placed on file.
Announcements: None
Public Comment: None
The meeting adjourned at 7:01 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Debra Neff
4
Introduced by the Finance Committee of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
At a ___________________ meeting of the Board of Commissioners of the County of Ingham
(the "County") held in the _________________________________, in the City of
_____________________, Michigan on ________________, 2000 __ at ______ p.m. Eastern
Standard Time, there were:
PRESENT:
___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
ABSENT: ___________________________________________________
The following preamble and resolution were offered by ___________________________ and seconded by _______________
____________________________.
RESOLUTION APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING
TERMINATION OF THE MICHIGAN GOVERNMENTAL INVESTMENT TRUST AND
APPROVING THE SECOND AMENDMENT TO THE INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT WITH VARIOUS COUNTIES, CITIES
AND TOWNSHIPS WHICH ESTABLISHED THE MICHIGAN
GOVERNMENT INVESTMENT TRUST
WHEREAS, Section 28 of Article 7 of the 1963 Constitution of the State of Michigan
provides, among other things, that the Legislature of the State of Michigan shall
authorize two or more municipalities to enter into contractual undertakings for the joint
administration of any functions each party would be separately empowered to perform, to
share costs and responsibilities of such functions, and to cooperate with one another; and
WHEREAS, Section 4 of Act No. 7 of the Public Acts of Michigan of 1967, Extra Session,
as amended, 124.501 et seq. of the Compiled Laws of Michigan [Act No. 7], provides that a
public agency of the State of Michigan may exercise jointly with any other public agency
of the State of Michigan any power, privilege or authority which such agencies share in
common and which each might exercise separately; and
WHEREAS, counties, cities, villages and townships ("public corporations") are
"public agencies" as defined in Act No. 7, as amended; and
WHEREAS, a number of public corporations of the State of Michigan (the
"Participants") established and organized a legal entity pursuant to Section 5
of Act No. 7, as amended, by entering into a Declaration of Trust for the purpose of
combining their available investment funds so as to enhance the investment opportunities
available to them by approving a Declaration of Trust which was also an Interlocal
Agreement made as of March 1, 1994 and amended as of January 1, 1997 thereby creating the
Michigan Government Investment Trust ("MIGIT").
WHEREAS, the Participants of MIGIT now believe it is in the best interest of the
participants that MIGIT be terminated.
WHEREAS, two thirds of the Participants may terminate MIGIT by approving the
termination of MIGIT and adopting an Amendment to Interlocal Agreement providing for such
termination of MIGIT on a date in the future.
WHEREAS, a Second Amendment to Declaration of Trust which is also a "Second
Amendment to Interlocal Agreement" has been prepared for these Public Corporations to
approve pursuant to Section 5 of Act No. 7, as amended, for the purpose of terminating
MIGIT.
WHEREAS, the governing board of two thirds of the Participants must duly adopt a
resolution approving this amendment before it becomes effective;
NOW THEREFORE it is resolved by the Board of Commissioners of the County of Ingham as
follows:
1. The Michigan Government Investment Trust shall be terminated effective January 31,
2001.
2. The Second Amendment to Agreement/Declaration of Trust dated as of January 1, 2001,
a copy of which is attached hereto as Appendix A, is hereby approved and the Chairperson
of the Board of Commissioners and the County Clerk are authorized to execute and deliver
the same.
3. A copy of this resolution shall be sent to the Secretary of the Board of Trustees of
MIGIT.
A ROLL CALL VOTE WAS TAKEN AS FOLLOWS:
YEAS: ______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
NAYS: ______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________
ABSTAIN: ______________________________________________________
THE RESOLUTION WAS DECLARED ADOPTED.
STATE OF MICHIGAN )
)ss.
COUNTY OF )
The undersigned, being the duly qualified and acting Clerk of the County of Ingham
hereby certified that the foregoing is a true and complete copy of a resolution duly
adopted by the County Board of Commissioners at its _____________ meeting held on the ___
day of ______________, 2000_, at which meeting a quorum was present and remained
throughout and that an original thereof is on file in the records of the County of Ingham.
I further certify that the meeting was conducted, and public notice thereof was given,
pursuant to and in full compliance with Act No. 267, Public Acts of Michigan of 1976, as
amended, and that minutes of such meeting were kept and will be or have been made
available as required thereby.
______________________________
County Clerk
DATED: __________________________, 2000_
ded/r-dis
APPENDIX A
SECOND AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT/DECLARATION OF TRUST
THIS SECOND AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT/DECLARATION OF TRUST dated as of the 1st day of
January, 2001 among the Township of Coe, the Charter Township of Meridian, the County of
Ingham, the County of Ogemaw, the County of Wexford, the County of Kalamazoo, the County
of Roscommon, and the County of Van Buren.
WHEREAS, Section 28 of Article 7 of the 1963 Constitution of the State of Michigan
provides, among other things, that the Legislature of the State of Michigan shall
authorize two or more municipalities to enter into contractual undertakings for the joint
administration of any functions each party would be separately empowered to perform, to
share costs and responsibilities of such functions, and to cooperate with one another; and
WHEREAS, Section 4 of Act No. 7 of the Public Acts of Michigan of 1967, Extra Session,
as amended, 124.501 et seq. of the Compiled Laws of Michigan [Act No. 7], provides that a
public agency of the State of Michigan may exercise jointly with any other public agency
of the State of Michigan any power, privilege or authority which such agencies share in
common and which each might exercise separately; and
WHEREAS, counties, cities, villages and townships ("public corporations") are
"public agencies" as defined in Act No. 7, as amended; and
WHEREAS, a number of public corporations of the State of Michigan (the
"Participants") established and organized a legal entity pursuant to Section 5
of Act No. 7, as amended, by entering into a Declaration of Trust for the purpose of
combining their available investment funds so as to enhance the investment opportunities
available to them by approving a Declaration of Trust which was also an Interlocal
Agreement made as of March 1, 1994 and amended as of January 1, 1997 thereby creating the
Michigan Government Investment Trust ("MIGIT").
WHEREAS, the Participants of MIGIT now believe it is in the best interest of the
participants that MIGIT be terminated.
WHEREAS, two thirds of the Participants may terminate MIGIT by adopting an Amendment to
Interlocal Agreement providing for the termination of MIGIT on a date in the future.
WHEREAS, An Amendment to Declaration of Trust which is also an "Amendment to
Interlocal Agreement" has been prepared for these Public Corporations to approve
pursuant to Section 5 of Act No. 7, as amended, for the purpose of terminating MIGIT.
WHEREAS, the governing board of two thirds of the Participants must duly adopt a
resolution approving this amendment before it becomes effective;
THE PARTICIPANTS TO THE AGREEMENT/DECLARATION OF TRUST made as of March 1, 1994, as
amended as of January 1, 1997 agree as follows:
The AGREEMENT/DECLARATION OF TRUST made as of March 1, 1994, as amended as of January
1, 1997, is amended by adding the following article to read as follows:
ARTICLE XVI
This Declaration of Trust shall terminate at 12:00 p.m. on the 31st day of January,
2001. Thereafter, the Trustees shall wind up the affairs of the Trust as provided in
Article XIII, Section 13.1 of this Declaration of Trust.
INFORMATION REGARDING EXECUTION
The Amendment/Declaration of Trust was executed on behalf of the Participants by the
persons indicated below as of January 1, 2001:
PARTICIPANT AUTHORIZED SIGNATURES
TOWNSHIP OF COE _______________________
Township Supervisor
_______________________
Township Clerk
CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF MERIDIAN _______________________
Township Supervisor
_______________________
Township Clerk
COUNTY OF INGHAM _______________________
Chairperson, Board of
Commissioners
_______________________
County Clerk
COUNTY OF OGEMAW _______________________
Chairperson, Board of
Commissioners
_______________________
County Clerk
COUNTY OF WEXFORD _______________________
Chairperson, Board of
Commissioners
_______________________
County Clerk
COUNTY OF KALAMAZOO _______________________
Chairperson, Board of
Commissioners
_______________________
County Clerk
COUNTY OF ROSCOMMON _______________________
Chairperson, Board of
Commissioners
_______________________
County Clerk
COUNTY OF VAN BUREN _______________________
Chairperson, Board of
Commissioners
_______________________
County Clerk
Return to top of document
Introduced by the Finance Committee of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO AMEND THE 2000 APPORTIONMENT REPORT
WHEREAS, the 2000 Apportionment Report was approved by Resolution #00-244; and
WHEREAS, subsequent to that approval certain corrections have become necessary.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that Resolution #00-244 be amended by substituting the
attached statement of state equalized valuations and the millage apportioned to the
various units in Ingham County for the year 2000.
RESOLUTION STAFF REVIEW DATE November 8, 2000
Agenda Item Title Resolution to Authorize a Contingency Fund Appropriation for the Circuit Court Family Division to Participate With
Verizon Communications for a Proposal to Provide 30 Cellular Phones
Submitted by Circuit Court
Committees: Ad.Ser/Per. , H.S. , Law & Cts. * , Finance *
Summary of Proposed Action This resolution is to authorize an appropriation of $2,308
from the 2000 Contingency Fund to the Circuit Court Family Division to finance the balance
of funds necessary to fund a proposal from Verizon Communications to provide 30 cellular
phones for Juvenile Officers.
Financial Implications Total cost of proposal - $27,715 (January 2001 - December 2002)
Funds budgeted currently in 2001 budget $12,000
Funds needed from 2000 Contingency 2,308
Funds to be budgeted in 2001 budget 13,407
$ 27,715 TOTAL
Other Implications The Family Division was directed by the Finance Committee of the Board of Commissioners to submit a resolution to authorize the balance of the necessary funds out of the 2000 Contingency Fund.
Staff Recommendation: JA DE JN * HH
This resolution should be approved.
Introduced by the Law & Courts and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE A CONTINGENCY FUND APPROPRIATION FOR THE CIRCUIT
COURT FAMILY DIVISION TO PARTICIPATE WITH VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS FOR A PROPOSAL TO PROVIDE
30 CELLULAR PHONES
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Board of Commissioners have an existing cellular phone
contract with Verizon Communications who gave the Family Division a cost proposal
effective through December 31, 2000; and
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Board of Commissioners have approved a total of $12,000 to
purchase 30 cellular phones in the Family Division 2001 budget; and
WHEREAS, the Family Division was directed by the Finance Committee of the Board of Commissioners to submit a resolution to authorize the balance of the necessary funds out of the 2000 Contingency Fund.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners approve the
Circuit Court Family Division to accept a proposal from Verizon Communications for the
provision of 30 cellular phones for the Juvenile Court Officers.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners approves an
appropriation of $2,308 from the 2000 Contingency Fund to the Circuit Court Family
Division to finance the balance of this proposal.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Controller is directed to adjust the 2000 budget in
accordance with this resolution.
RESOLUTION STAFF REVIEW DATE September 28, 2000
Agenda Item Title Resolution Authorizing Improvements in the Holding
Cell and Attorney Rooms in the Ingham County Jail
Submitted by Sheriff's Office
Committees: Ad.Ser/Per. * , H.S. , Law & Cts. * , Finance *
Summary of Proposed Action The attached resolution will authorize the Sheriff's Office to
expend up to $14,000.00 to make the necessary improvements in the holding cell and the
Attorney Rooms in the jail as recommended by Jack Kann, Manager of the County Jail Service
Unit of DOC.
Financial Implications The Sheriff's Office is requesting up to $14,000 from
Contingency fund for this purpose.
$ 1,500 - Attorney Room furniture
$11,900 - Cost estimate for improvements to Jail Holding cell
$ 600 - Project contingency
______
Total $14,000
Other Implications - The Office of Purchasing will solicit 3 verbal quotes for the
installation of the tile. Estimated cost is $2,350.00. The Office of Purchasing will put
out a formal RFP that will be advertised for the plumbing contract work. Estimated cost is
$8,084.00. Purchasing will pre-qualify the bidders in that only plumbers with experience
working in a Jail setting will be allowed to bid on this project. Purchasing feels we need
a company that has the experience in working in secure correctional settings and agrees
with the recommendations from the D.O.C. that this work needs to be done.
Staff Recommendation: JA DE JN * HH
This resolution should be approved.
MEMORANDUM
Administrative Services/Personnel
Finance Committee
From: John Neilsen, Deputy Controller
Subject: Resolution Authorizing Improvements in the Holding Cell and Attorney Rooms in the Ingham County Jail
Date: November 16, 2000
Commissioners:
The Law & Courts Committee tabled the attached resolution at their November 2, 2000
meeting. It is now back before you at this round of Committee meetings.
Several issues were raised at that meeting, and those issues and the appropriate
responses are as follows:
1) Are there going to be any other capital improvements' cost items that are going to
be identified and brought back to the Board from this DOC Inspection?
Response: The Sheriff's Office does not have any other capital improvements' cost items
that are going to be identified and brought back to the Board from this specific DOC
Inspection.
2) What authority does the DOC have to require us to do this?
Response: In general, the Michigan DOC has the specific statutory authority to
supervise and inspect jails that are under the jurisdiction of the county sheriff and to
promulgate rules and standards for the proper administration of the jails. On these
specific recommendations, our main concern is our potential liability IF something should
happen now that we have been advised of the potential problems and fail to take specific
actions to remedy the situation. I want to make clear that our Purchasing & Properties
office has reviewed the DOC recommendations contained in this resolution and are
recommending these capital improvements at the jail.
3) The Committee asked for a clarification of this statement in the cover review sheet:
"Purchasing will pre-qualify the bidders in that only plumbers with experience
working in a Jail setting will be allowed to bid on this project. Purchasing feels we need
a company that has the experience in working in secure correctional settings".
Response: Purchasing does not have a list of qualified vendors for bidding on work at the
Jail. This statement means that they will give consideration and preferences for any
contractors that have experience in working in secure correctional settings, but it is not
an absolute requirement. Price, quality of work and this experience are all factors that
will be considered during the review of the proposal process, but any vendor will be able
to submit proposals for this work. The successful vendor will have an absolute requirement
to have all of their employees successfully pass a security background check to work
within the jail.
I hope this communication provides the information you need as you deliberate this resolution.
Representatives of the Sheriff's Office will be at the various committee meetings. If
you should have any other questions, please feel free to contact me at any time.
c: Matt Myers
John Andresen
Jim Hudgins
COUNTY of INGHAM
State of Michigan
SHERIFF'S OFFICE
Gene L. Wriggelsworth 630 North Cedar Street
Sheriff Mason, Mi 48854
(517) 676-2431
Matthew J. Myers, Ph.D. FAX (517) 676-8299
Undersheriff
TO: Mr. John Neilsen, Deputy Controller
FROM: Matthew J. Myers, Undersheriff
DATE: October 13, 2000
Please find enclosed the County Jail Inspection Report from the Department of
Corrections. You will note in the numerous comments from DOC that all reference to the
holding cell that had been previously discussed has been eliminated. I've also included a
copy of the memo dated August 30, 2000, from Jack Kann, Manager of the County Jail Service
Unit of DOC to Sheriff Wriggelsworth. You will note the recommendations made in reference
to the holding cell in this memo. This was not included in the final DOC reports, as
discussions between Major Carpenter and Mr. Kann, prior to the final report, included the
upgrades in this holding cell. As a result, and under the belief that these improvements
were going to be made, these were left out of the final Inspection Report.
However, with the recommendations from the August 30, 2000 letter, I believe it is
important we move forward and make the improvements as recommended. The attached
Resolution should address those.
MJM/jp
cc: Sheriff Gene L. Wriggelsworth
Major Michael Carpenter
Introduced by the Law & Courts, Administrative Services/Personnel and Finance
Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING IMPROVEMENTS IN THE HOLDING CELL
AND ATTORNEY ROOMS IN THE INGHAM COUNTY JAIL
WHEREAS, the Department of Corrections has recommended several improvements to the
Ingham County Jail; and
WHEREAS, those improvements include removing carpeting and installing tile or sealed
concrete flooring, fixed concrete bench, and prisoner type water closet in a holding cell
in Receiving; and
WHEREAS, the MDOC recommendations also include removing metal frame chairs from
Attorney Rooms, and replacing them with institutional chairs; and
WHEREAS, these recommendations were made through an MDOC inspection in August, 2000.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
transfer from the 2000 Contingency Fund to the appropriate budget and the expenditure of
up to $14,000.00 to make the necessary improvements in the holding cell and the Attorney
Rooms in the jail.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
award contracts to the contractor(s) with the best proposal(s) as determined by the
Controller after Purchasing & Properties conducts their procurement process in
accordance with Ingham County Procurement and Purchasing Policies.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
Board Chairperson and the County Clerk to sign any necessary contract documents for these
improvements approved as to form by the County Attorney and consistent with this
resolution.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
Controller's Office to make the necessary budget adjustments in the Sheriff's Office 2000
Budget.
Return to top of document
RESOLUTION STAFF REVIEW DATE October 28, 2000
Agenda Item Title Resolution to Accept a Grant from O.H.S.P. to
Conduct Special Traffic Enforcement Programs
Submitted by Sheriff's Office
Committees: Ad.Ser/Per. , H.S. , Law & Cts. * , Finance *
Summary of Proposed Action The attached resolution will authorize the Sheriff's Office
to accept a Grant for participation in a statewide public information and enforcement
campaign with local, state and county law enforcement agencies for specialized Traffic
Enforcement. The three specific points of emphasis; 1) seat belt and child restraint use
(Operation ABC); 2) alcohol impaired driving (Operation Nightcap); and 3) summer traffic
enforcement (local traffic problem and seat belt use). The County would accept the grant
from O.H.S.P. and then subcontract a portion of the funds to the other law enforcement
agencies. No match is required and the County portion would be used for Overtime costs.
Each department would get about 250 hours of overtime for enforcement
Financial Implications The Grant from the O.H.S.P. to conduct special traffic
enforcement programs would allocate the funds as follows:
Ingham County Sheriffs Office $ 9,970.33
East Lansing Police Department 10,014.57
Lansing Police Department 10,018.05
Meridian Township Police Department 9,987.29
TOTAL $39,990.24
Other Implications The Sheriff's Office has participated in these grant programs for a
number of years now.
Staff Recommendation: JA DE JN * HH
This resolution should be approved.
Introduced by the Law & Courts and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION ACCEPT A GRANT FROM O.H.S.P. TO CONDUCT SPECIAL TRAFFIC
ENFORCEMENT PROGRAMS
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Sheriff's Office applied for and has received a grant from
the Office of Highway Safety and Planning to conduct special traffic enforcement programs;
and
WHEREAS, this grant is in cooperation with the Lansing Police Department, the East
Lansing Police Department and the Meridian Township Police Department; and
WHEREAS, the grant amount totals $39,990.00 with no matching funds necessary from
Ingham County; and
WHEREAS, the grant will provide special traffic enforcement programs to target
violations specifically: seat belt, child restraint, impaired driving, and summer traffic
enforcement; and
WHEREAS, the intent of the grant and the special traffic enforcement programs are to
save lives in Ingham County.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
acceptance of the Michigan O.H.S.P. grant in the amount of $39,990.24 to provide special
traffic enforcement in Ingham County from October 1, 2000 through September 30, 2001.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the following subcontracts are also authorized for the
same time period:
East Lansing Police Department $10,014.57
Lansing Police Department $10,018.05
Meridian Township Police Department $ 9,987.29
TOTAL $30,019.91
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
Ingham County Clerk and the Ingham County Board Chairperson to sign any necessary contract
agreements that are consistent with this resolution and approved as to form by the County
Attorney.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
Controller to make any necessary adjustments in the Ingham County Sheriff's Office 2000
and 2001 budgets.
RESOLUTION STAFF REVIEW DATE October 28, 2000
Agenda Item Title Resolution to Allow the Ingham County Sheriff's Office to Purchase
Unbudgeted Laser Radar Units
Submitted by Sheriff's Office
Committees: Ad.Ser/Per. , H.S. , Law & Cts. * , Finance *
Summary of Proposed Action The attached resolution will authorize the Sheriff's Office to
expend up to $20,000.00 to purchase new radar units for squad cars out of the
contingency fund.
Financial Implications The Sheriff's Office is requesting up to $20,000 from
contingency fund for this purpose.
$20,000 will purchase 4 Laser radar units. ($5,000 * 4 units)
$311,000.00 in the 2000-2001 Secondary Road Patrol Budget was verified as the revenue for the 2000-2001 Grant year which is $81,000 over the original estimate of $230,000. The Finance Committee and BOC adopted a 2001 budget recognizing an additional $72,000 used for the Strategic Planning initiative funds.
Other Implications
The Finance Committee recognized the new revenue for FY 2001 and suggested that the
Sheriff's Office request these funds - 4 Laser radar units. ($5,000 * 4 units = $20,000)
from the 2000 Contingency fund during the budget hearings for Law & Courts.
Staff Recommendation: JA DE JN * HH
This resolution should be approved.
COUNTY of INGHAM
State of Michigan
SHERIFF'S OFFICE
Gene L. Wriggelsworth 630 North Cedar Street
Sheriff Mason, Mi 48854
(517) 676-2431
Matthew J. Myers, Ph.D. FAX (517) 676-8299
Undersheriff
TO: Mr. John Neilsen, Deputy Controller
FROM: Matthew J. Myers, Undersheriff
DATE: October 19, 2000
RE: Secondary Road Patrol
As you are aware, and as was discussed in the Budget Hearings, the Sheriff's Office
received approximately $81,000 in unexpected revenue for the 2000 -2001 Secondary Road
Patrol budget. As was discussed during the Budget Hearings, I would request the Ingham
County Sheriff's Office be allowed to use $20,000 to purchase traffic laser units for the
patrol units. Several of our radar units are old and outdated, and this new technology
will greatly assist the Ingham County Sheriff's Office to modernize traffic enforcement,
and further assist our efforts in continually providing the necessary revenue to Secondary
Road Patrol.
The remaining unbudgeted revenue would go toward the Ingham County General Fund. The
attached Resolution allows the Controller's Office, Budgeting Office and Finance Office to
make the necessary adjustments.
MJM/jp
Introduced by the Law & Courts and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO ALLOW THE INGHAM COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
TO PURCHASE UNBUDGETED LASER RADAR UNITS
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Sheriff's Office had budgeted approximately $230,000.00 in
revenue from Secondary Road Patrol; and
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Sheriff's Office was notified by the Office of Highway and
Safety Planning that we would be receiving approximately $311,000.00 in the 2000-2001
Secondary Road Patrol Budget; and
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Sheriff's Office is in need of purchasing laser units for
Road Patrol vehicles.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
Ingham County Sheriff's Office to spend up to $20,000.00 from 2000 contingency funds
toward the purchase of four laser units for traffic enforcement.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes that
the Board Chairperson and the County Clerk sign any necessary purchase/contract documents
that are consistent with this resolution and approved as to form by the County Attorney.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
Controller's Office to make the necessary adjustments in the Ingham County Sheriff's
Office 2000 and 2001 budgets.
Introduced by Commissioner Randy Schafer of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO ADOPT A 911 EMERGENCY TELEPHONE DISPATCH
SERVICES FUND ALLOCATION POLICY
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Board of Commissioners has established a 911 Emergency
Telephone Dispatch Services fund for both operational costs and management and system
improvements to the County emergency dispatch system; and
WHEREAS, traditionally the Board of Commissioners has operated under an informal policy
of reserving at least twenty percent (20%) of the total annual revenues from the millage
and the telephone surcharge has been reserved for management and system improvements to
the County emergency dispatch system and the remaining eighty percent (80%) has been
reserved forcontracting with the Cities of Lansing and East Lansing and the Northeast
Ingham Emergency Services Authority for the Provision of 911 and Emergency Telephone
Dispatch Service; and
WHEREAS, the County has been reimbursing the Cities of Lansing and East Lansing and the
Northeast Ingham Emergency Services Authority for the Provision of 911 and Emergency
telephone dispatch service for ninety five percent (95%) of the eligible operational costs
for several years; and
WHEREAS, in fiscal year 2000-01 for the first time the operational contracts exceeded
eighty percent (80%) of the total annual revenues from the millage and the telephone
surcharge; and
WHEREAS, both are critical needs for public safety in Ingham County but a sufficient
amount of funds must be reserved to maintain the integrity of the infrastructure of the
Ingham County emergency telephone dispatch service.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners hereby adopts a
"911 Emergency Telephone Dispatch Services Fund Allocation Policy" that
effective with the 2001-02 fiscal year twenty-five per cent (25%) of the total annual
revenues from the millage and the telephone surcharge will be reserved for management and
system improvements to the County emergency dispatch system and the remaining seventy five
percent (75%) will be capped and reserved to reimburse the Cities of Lansing and East
Lansing and the Northeast Ingham Emergency Services Authority for the Provision of 911 and
emergency telephone dispatch service for up to ninety five percent (95%) of the eligible
operational costs.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the County Clerk is directed to submit copies of this
resolution to the City of Lansing, City of East Lansing, the Northeast Ingham Emergency
Services Authority, and the 911 Advisory Committee.
Return to top of document
RESOLUTION STAFF REVIEW DATE November 9, 2000
Agenda Item Title Resolution Authorizing the Sale of
Equipment from the Ingham County Correctional Facility
Submitted by: Purchasing & Properties
Committees: Ad.Ser/Per. * , H.S. , Law & Cts. , Finance *
Summary of Proposed Action: This resolution authorizes the sale of used kitchen
equipment from the Ingham County Correctional Facility. Bids were solicited, and
Purchasing recommends selling the equipment to the Chief Okemos Council of the Boy Scouts
of America for $100.00. Commercial Services & Installation has viewed that the kitchen
equipment has no resale value.
Financial Implications: None
Other Implications: None
Staff Recommendation: JA DE * JN HH
This resolution should be approved.
Introduced by the Administrative Services/Personnel and Finance
Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE SALE OF KITCHEN EQUIPMENT FROM THE INGHAM
COUNTY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Correctional Facility has used kitchen equipment; and
WHEREAS, Commercial Service & Installation has deemed the kitchen equipment having
no resale value; and
WHEREAS, the Office of Purchasing solicited sealed bids for the sale of the used
kitchen equipment; and
WHEREAS, the Office of Purchasing received one bid for $100.00 for the used kitchen
equipment.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Office of Purchasing recommends selling the used
kitchen equipment to the Chief Okemos Council of the Boy Scouts of America for $100.00.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes the
County Controller, County Clerk and the Sheriff's Office to sign any necessary documents
selling the kitchen equipment to the Chief Okemos Council of the Boy Scouts of America.
RESOLUTION STAFF REVIEW: DATE: November 9, 2000
Agenda Item Title: Restructuring of Ingham County Prosecuting Attorney's Switchboard Operator Position
Submitted By: Harold Hailey, Human Resources Director
Committees: Ad.Ser/Per * , H.S. , Law & Cts , Fin. *
Summary of Proposed Action: Approval of this request would reclassify the Switchboard
Operator Position based on additional duties.
Financial Implications: Money is within the budget.
Other Implications: This action was reviewed and accepted by the Union.
Staff Recommendation: JA DE JN HH *
This resolution should be approved.
Introduced by the Administrative Services/Personnel and Finance Committees:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING RESTRUCTURING OF INGHAM COUNTY PROSECUTING
ATTORNEY'S SWITCHBOARD OPERATOR POSITION
WHEREAS, the Switchboard Operator position is vacant and has been restructured to include additional duties and responsibilities; and
WHEREAS, the Human Resources Department has evaluated these changes and recommend the
title be changed to Information Clerk - Prosecuting Attorney with a grade level change
from Level B to Level C; and
WHEREAS, the UAW has been notified of this change and have not offered any opposition;
and
WHEREAS, there is money in the Prosecuting Attorney's Budget to accommodate this change.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that Position #PRSATY041 be changed from Switchboard Operator Level B to "Information Clerk/Prosecuting Attorney" Level C effective December 1, 2000.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the funds necessary for this change be taken from the
existing budget to be provided when the salary and wage accounts are adjusted on a
quarterly basis.
MEMORANDUM
To: Human Services Committee
Finance Committee
From: Bruce Bragg
Date: November 16, 2000
Subject: Countywide Recycling Plan
This will communicate the Health Department's plan to distribute funds to
municipalities to support recycling efforts.
I anticipate that the MDEQ Director will approve the Solid Waste Plan Update before
December 31, 2000. The Health Department is preparing to implement the new Solid Waste
Plan effective January 1, 2001. With the implementation of the new Plan, the Board will
require that any of the eighteen solid waste disposal facilities authorized in the Plan
must enter into an agreement with the County in order to accept waste generated in Ingham
County. The Department will be sending out proposed agreements to the eighteen eligible
solid waste disposal sites by November 15, 2000 with the intent of having these agreements
fully executed by January 1, 2001.
The facilities that sign agreements and accept Ingham County solid waste will be
required to remit to Ingham County $0.42 for each cubic yard of waste received which
originated within the County. The County will then distribute $0.36 per cubic yard to the
municipalities in the County that operate recycling programs. Attached are materials that
describe the Health Department's plan to distribute the funds to support recycling
activities throughout the County.
The Board of Commissioners has already authorized contracts with the municipalities and
entities operating recycling programs. The Department proposes to contract with eight
different municipalities, including Michigan State University, to implement the countywide
recycling concept. In several cases, more than one township or municipality would be
served by a recycling center. We anticipate contracting only with municipalities that
offer a fairly comprehensive recycling program that is reasonably available to the
community it serves. This would mean that programs focusing on single items, such a
newspapers, would not qualify. And it would mean that programs that are open for only a
few hours a month or only during the working day may not qualify for funding.
Bob Godbold, Jim Wilson and I will appreciate knowing of any concerns the Board of
Commissioners has regarding the proposed plan.
Attachments
cc: Bob Godbold w/attachment
Jim Wilson w/attachment
Naomi Gaynor w/attachment
Ingham County Municipalities w/attachment
ADOPTED - APRIL 25, 2000
Introduced by the Human Services and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION APPROVING THE INGHAM COUNTY
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN UPDATE
RESOLUTION #00-091
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Board of Commissioners has adopted a Solid Waste Management
Plan ("Plan") under the authority of PA 641 of 1978 as amended; and
WHEREAS, PA 451 Part 115 as amended requires the Board to periodically update the Plan
in light of changing circumstances; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners appointed a Solid Waste Planning Committee and
designated the Health Department as the Designated Planning Agency which serves as staff
to the Committee in October of 1997; and
WHEREAS, the Solid Waste Planning Committee (SWPC) completed a first draft of the
updated solid waste management plan in March of 1999; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners sent the first Draft of the Plan Update back to the
Planning Committee with a statement of objections to the Plan Update; and
WHEREAS, the County's Solid Waste Planning Committee has considered the objections and
has recommended a revised Plan Update; and
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Board of Commissioners has reviewed the proposed Plan Update
and several amendments which would address all the objections as stated by the Board
through Resolution # 00-23; and
WHEREAS, the Board generally determines that the Plan Update with these amendments
promotes and protects the solid waste needs and interests of the citizens of Ingham
County.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners hereby approves
the Solid Waste Management Plan Update as recommended by the Solid Waste Planning
Committee and as amended by the Board of Commissioners.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the County's Designated Planning Agency (Health
Department) is directed to seek the approval of the Plan Update by the municipalities of
the County as required by PA 451 Part 115 and upon such approval to forward the Plan
Update to the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality ("MDEQ") for its
approval.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that upon the approval by the MDEQ of the Plan Update that the
Plan Update shall supersede and replace any prior Plans.
HUMAN SERVICES: Yeas: Czarnecki, Smiley, Grebner Nays: Schmidt, Severino
Absent: None Approved 4/17/00
FINANCE: Yeas: Bernero, Grebner, Czarnecki, McDonald, Schafer, Minter, Juall
Nays: None Absent: None Approved 4/19/00
MEMORANDUM
To: Human Services Committee
Finance Committee
From: Bruce Bragg
Date: November 16, 2000
Subject: MDEQ Proposed Modifications to the Solid
Waste Plan Update
The Michigan Department of Environment Quality has advised that a number of
modifications must be made to the Solid Waste Plan Update in order for it to be approved
by the MDEQ. The proposed recommendations have been reviewed by staff in the Health
Department and the Controller's Office, as well as by Naomi Gaynor of Cohl, Stoker, and
Toskey. All parties find the proposed recommendations to be non-substantive.
The MDEQ has advised that with the approval of the Board of Commissioners, the proposed
modifications can be administratively appended to the Solid Waste Plan Update as part of
the Plan approval process. With support of staff, I am recommending that the Board of
Commissioners accept the MDEQ recommended modifications and approve the MDEQ
administratively appending them to the Solid Waste Plan Update as part of the Plan
approval process.
The MDEQ proposed modifications are attached to this communication in two forms: the
first being a copy of the October 23, 2000 letter transmitting them to James Wilson, and
the second being the bill draft form, showing where they would modify the language of the
Plan Update, by adding or deleting original language.
I recommend that the Board of Commissioners accept the changes and authorize the MDEQ
Director to move forward to approve the Plan Update. Attached is a resolution to implement
that recommendation. With such approval, I believe the MDEQ Director will approve the Plan
prior to December 31, 2000.
Attachment
cc: Bob Godbold w/attachment
Naomi Gaynor w/attachment
James Wilson w/attachment
Return to top of document
Introduced by the Human Services and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO ACCEPT MODIFICATION TO THE INGHAM COUNTY SOLID WASTE PLAN
UPDATE PROPOSED BY THE MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Board of Commissioners has adopted a Solid Waste Plan Update
after substantial work by the Ingham County Solid Waste Planning Committee to develop and
recommend the update to the 1990 Solid Waste Management Plan; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners submitted the Solid Waste Plan Update to the
Director of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (MDEQ) for consideration and
approval; and
WHEREAS, the MDEQ has advised that a number of modifications to the Plan must be made
in order for the Plan to be acceptable to MDEQ Director; and
WHEREAS, the MDEQ proposed modifications have been reviewed by the Health Department
and Controller's staff and also by the County Attorney, with the conclusion that the
changes are editorial in nature and not substantive; and
WHEREAS, the Health Officer recommends that the Board of Commissioners approve of the
MDEQ modifications and agree to have the MDEQ administratively make these modifications to
the Plan as part of the MDEQ approval of the Plan.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners' MDEQ proposed
modifications, included in the October 23, 2000 letter to Mr. James R. Wilson from Lynn
Dumroese, Solid Waste Management Unit, and supports the MDEQ administratively making these
modifications to the Plan as part of the MDEQ approval of the Plan.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Health Officer is directed to communicate this
acceptance to the MDEQ Director.
MEMORANDUM
To: Human Services Committee
Finance Committee
From: Bruce Bragg
Date: November 16, 2000
Subject: Resolution to Authorize a Record Copying Agreement with Smart Corporation
This is a recommendation to authorize a contract to copy records with Smart
Corporation. The Health Department maintains medical records for tens of thousands of
patients. There are many reasons why these records need to be copied and provided to other
authorized persons and offices. Medical records are confidential documents and will only
be copied by the Department when the patient has authorized such copying or when there is
another legal basis for such record sharing, such as a court order.
The act of copying and sending records to other parties has become a significant burden
to the staff in our clinic operations. This staff has identified a firm that does this
service and is compensated by other parties, some of the parties that receive the records.
Smart Corporation will come to the Health Department to copy records within twelve
hours of any such request. They will abide by all County and Department policies, state
and federal statutes and rules regarding the confidentiality of client/patient records.
Smart Corporation compensation will consist entirely of payments collected from
prepayments made by the entities requesting such records.
Patient will not be charged for a copy of their own record. Certain other parties will
not be charged for copies of such records: such as hospitals, nursing homes, Medicaid,
Friend of the Court, schools, jails and prisons and law enforcement agencies. Billable
parties will include: attorneys, insurance companies, the Social Security Administration,
the Family Independence Agency, copying services and record deposit services.
The Smart Corporation has agreed to copy as many non-billable charts as billable charts
and records. Copying non-billable charts above the 1:1 ration will be the responsibility
of the Health Department. We do not anticipate this arrangement to result in any charges
to the County.
I recommend that the Board of Commissioners adopt the attached resolution and authorize
a one year agreement. It will result in needed relief of effort for the clerical staff of
the Department clinical units.
Attachment
cc: Bruce Miller w/attachment
John Jacobs w/attachment
Introduced by the Human Services and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE AN AGREEMENT WITH SMART CORPORATION
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Health Department maintains medical records for many
thousands of clients; and
WHEREAS, there is a regular need to share these records, or summaries of these records,
with proper authorization and purpose, with other health care providers, government
offices and attorneys; and
WHEREAS, the task of copying and mailing such records has grown and now represents a
strain on the resources of the Department; and
WHEREAS, Department staff have identified Smart Corporation as providing confidential
services to copy records and provide them to other authorized providers, government
offices and attorneys; and
WHEREAS, Smart Corporation will conform to all Department policies, state and federal
laws and rules pertaining to confidentiality of medical records; and
WHEREAS, Smart Corporation will be compensated by the provider, government office or attorney receiving the copy of such records, and that certain parties shall be provided copies of records without payment; and
WHEREAS, the Health Officer recommends that the Board of Commissioners authorize the
agreement with Smart Corporation because it will save valuable resources in the
Department's clinical units.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes a
one year agreement with Smart Corporation for record copying services.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, Smart Corporation will copy medical and other records of the
Department, when such records have been authorized for copying by the patient, guardian,
state statute or court, and that the Corporation shall be compensated for such services by
billing certain parties receiving such records.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that Corporation shall comply with all County and Department
policies and with all state and federal statutes and rules related to confidentiality of
patient/client information.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that billable parties shall include: attorneys, insurance companies, such government agencies as the Social Security Administration and the Family Independence Agency, copy services and record deposit services; and that non-billable parties
shall include hospitals, nursing homes, Medicaid, Friend of the Court, schools, jails
and prisons, law enforcement agencies and patient advocates.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that Ingham County will be charged for copying services only if
and when the number of records copied for non-billable purposes exceeds the number of
records copied for billable purposes.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Board Chairperson is authorized to sign the agreement
with Smart Corporation after review by the County Attorney.
MEMORANDUM
To: Human Services Committee
Finance Committee
From: Bruce Bragg
Date: November 16, 2000
Subject: Recommendation to Contract with Children's Choice
of Michigan to Coordinate Services for Families with Children with Special Health Care
Services Needs
This is a recommendation to authorize an agreement with Children's Choice of Michigan
to assure cooperation and coordination with the Ingham County Health Department's Locally
Based Services Unit. This Unit tracks all families in Ingham County who have children
eligible for the State's Children's Special Health Care Services Program (CSHCS). The
CSHCS program acts as an insurance program for families with children who have severe
handicapping conditions. The Locally Based Service Units in local health departments are
set up and funded by the State to provide information to such families, to assist in the
coordination of services to such families and to provide case management services for a
few of these families.
On the medical side, the State is trying to create incentives for families to enroll
such children in organized health plans set up to provide a specified scope of benefits to
each enrolled child in return for a fixed capitation payment. Children's Choice of
Michigan is a subsidarary of Detroit Medical Center and is set up to provide such a scope
of services to CSHCS eligible children. Children's Choice will be operating in Ingham
County and the State has recommended that a formal agreement be executed between Ingham
County the Children's Choice to facilitate cooperation and coordination of services on
behalf of CSHCS children and their families.
Attached is resolution to authorize such an agreement. I recommend that the Board adopt
the resolution and authorize the agreement.
Attachment
cc: Anita Turner w/attachment
Bruce Miller w/attachment
Introduced by the Human Services and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE A CONTRACT WITH CHILDREN'S CHOICE OF MICHIGAN
WHEREAS, the State of Michigan has operated a set of services to assist families with
children having need of special health care services; and
WHEREAS, these children have health conditions requiring extensive health care services
and often requiring the coordination of services by many health care providers in a
community; and
WHEREAS, the Michigan Department of Community Health supports a set of resources in
local health departments throughout Michigan to provide assistance to families in the
community having children with special health care services needs; and
WHEREAS, the MDCH has also attempted to improve the coordination of medical services
provided to children with special health care needs by creating the formation of health
care systems to serve this population; and
WHEREAS, Children's Choice of Michigan, a subsidiary of the Detroit Medical Center is
one of the health systems formed to serve children with special health care service needs,
and Children's Choice will now be operational in Ingham County; and
WHEREAS, the MDCH encourages formal agreements between the local health departments
providing support and service coordination to families with special health care needs and
the medical systems set up to provide most of the medical services needed; and
WHEREAS, the Health Officer has recommended that the Ingham County Board of
Commissioners enter into a contract with Children's Choice of Michigan to coordinate
services provided to Ingham County families having children with special health care
service needs.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes an
agreement with Children's Choice of Michigan, Detroit Medical Center, to facilitate
coordination of services for children with special health care needs with the Locally
Based Services Unit of the Ingham County Health Department.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Board Chairperson is authorized to sign
the agreement after review by the County Attorney.
MEMORANDUM
To: Human Services Committee
Finance Committee
From: Bruce Bragg
Date: November 16, 2000
Subject: Recommendation to Appropriate Funds to Support the Ingham Health Plan's Subsidized Health Insurance Program for Low Wage Paying Firms
This is a recommendation to appropriate funds to support the Ingham Health Plan
Corporation's subsidized health insurance program for low wage paying Ingham County
businesses. The Ingham County Board of Commissioners has a goal of assuring access for all
County residents to organized systems of health care. The Ingham Health Plan Corporation
was formed with the purpose of providing health care benefits and health insurance to low
income, uninsured Ingham County residents.
There are between 25,000-30,000 residents of Ingham County who are uninsured. The
Ingham Health Plan Corporation plan to implement a subsidized health insurance program for
small employers projected to provide health insurance to 2,500 by the fourth year (2004).
The program would be implemented by local health insurers or Health Maintenance
Organizations offering the subsidized products to low wage paying businesses in Ingham
County. The Ingham Health Plan would provide up to one third of the premium payment, with
the other two thirds to come from the employer and the employee. It is anticipated that
the monthly premium would be about $120 per person covered. The IHP would provide $40 per
month and the other $80 would come from the employer and the employee.
The proposed subsidized health insurance program for small employers is one of several
strategies to address the problem of the uninsured in Ingham County. With implementation
of this program, along with other initiatives now under development at IHP, we are nearing
the limit of what can be done to deal with this problem in the absence of a broad-based
state or national solution.
From the perspective of IHP, the County's approach will have three main components:
1) The IHP Board views the basic IHP program as the minimum level of coverage which
should be available to any Ingham County resident for whom no alternative is available. By
year-end, the basic IHP program of coverage will have reached approximately 14,000 Ingham
County residents, or roughly half of the County's uninsured. Depending on the success of
other IHP initiatives, as listed below, some expansion of this program may be required
over the next several years.
2) The IHP is working with Michigan State University to develop a plan to address the
problems faced by uninsured persons associated with the university community. This group,
which we estimate to be in the range of 3,000-5,000, may require programs different from
those applicable to the rest of the County's uninsured. As presently contemplated, any
needed funding for this initiative will come from MSU and the usual matching sources. If
this can be accomplished, a large and particularly challenging part of the problem in
Ingham County will have been addressed. To the extent that IHP is successful in this area,
fewer individuals associated with the university will require coverage under the basic IHP
program.
3) The proposed subsidized health insurance program for small employers represents
IHP's main effort to directly address the largest group of the uninsured: those who are
employed but have no coverage. As discussed above, it may be possible to achieve a
membership of 2,500 persons through IHP's proposed program. It should be recognized,
however, that many small employers will not be willing to provide health insurance even if
a subsidy is available. Therefore, for employees of these firms, IHP's basic program will
be the only alternative. Similarly, for many part-time workers and dependents of workers
who are not eligible for coverage, IHP's basic program may be the only option.
Nevertheless, to the extent that any uninsured persons can be brought into
employer-sponsored health insurance arrangements, there will be less need for coverage
under the basic IHP program.
Taken together, these three approaches may bring us close to the practical limit of
what can be done at the local level. Short of a systematic state or national solution,
there will always be at least a few persons outside of the insurance system. If, between
these three approaches, we can reduce the number of such people in Ingham County to a few
thousand, we may conclude that we have accomplished all that it is possible to do.
With these understandings in mind, I recommend that the Board of Commissioners
appropriate $1.05 million from the Ingham Regional Medical Center payments to settle its
in-kind obligation. That portion of the annual payment that is made in cash is
contractually obligated to be expended primarily for public health purposes. I recommend
that the appropriation be made from the funds reserved for these purposes. I recommend
that the Controller be authorized to utilize these funds to maximize revenues for the
purposes of implementing the subsidized health insurance program. Each year for the next
four years a portion of these funds can be transferred to the State of Michigan to form
part of DSH (Disproportionate Share Hospital) payments to Ingham Regional Medical Center
and Sparrow Health System. The hospitals will contribute the funds, including the Federal
portion of about 105% of the local contribution, to the Ingham Health Plan Corporation via
Indigent Care Agreements. The IHP will utilize the funds to implement the subsidized
health insurance program.
I recommend that the Board of Commissioners adopt the attached resolution and take the
next step toward assuring Ingham County residents have access to organized systems of
care. Also attached to this communication is a copy of an August 24, 2000 memorandum from
me to Jerry Ambrose providing more detail on this recommendation.
Attachments
cc: Jerry Ambrose w/attachment
Jay Rosen w/attachment
Jay Rising w/attachment
Ingham Health Plan Board
Bruce Miller w/attachment
Return to top of document
MEMORANDUM
August 24, 2000
To: Jerry Ambrose
From: Bruce Bragg
Re: Ingham Health Plan/Proposed Subsidized Health Insurance Program for Small Employers
Introduction
As you know, the Ingham Health Plan (IHP) has proved to be a highly successful vehicle
for addressing the problems of financial access to health care in Ingham County. In its
first two years of operation, it has enrolled almost 12,000 uninsured Ingham County
residents into a cost-effective, structured program of health coverage. By year-end, IHP
expects to have a total of 14,000 members.
Recently, the IHP board reviewed the concept of a subsidized health insurance plan that
could be made available to small employers in Ingham County that do not currently provide
health insurance benefits to employees. As discussed below, the IHP board views this
initiative as an important additional tool through which the problems of financial access
in the county may be resolved.
The purpose of this memorandum is to briefly recapitulate what we know about the
problem of the uninsured in Ingham County, to outline the IHP's proposal for a subsidized
health insurance program, and to describe a proposed implementation plan and funding
scheme for such a program. I am proposing that the County commit to a contribution to the
subsidized insurance plan for five years: 2000 - 2004, from the cash payments from Ingham
Regional to settle the in-kind obligation with the County.
The Uninsured in Ingham County
Based on various studies and surveys that have been conducted over the past several
years, it is estimated that the overall number of uninsured persons in Ingham County is
25,000-30,000. These figures represent 9-11% of the 285,000 residents of the county, and
are consistent with numerous state and national analyses.
In considering these numbers, it is important to keep in mind that the population of
uninsured persons includes a variety of subgroups. For example, some of these persons are
indigent and unemployed, but, for various reasons, do not qualify for the main programs of
medical assistance such as Medicaid and CHIP. Some of the uninsured are college students
who, though not usually thought of as indigent, nevertheless cannot afford health
insurance. Many other uninsured persons are employed, or live in households in which
someone is employed, but work for firms that do not provide health insurance benefits.
Still others may work for firms that provide benefits, but only for full-time workers or
for the workers themselves and not dependents.
It is very difficult to know how many persons fall into these various categories.
However, it seems clear that the majority of the uninsured persons in Ingham County are
employed or live in households in which some household member is employed. In fact, we
estimate that there are approximately 20,000-22,000 uninsured residents of Ingham County
who are employed or who live in households in which some member of the household is
employed. We know, for example, that a large number of current IHP members (i.e., roughly
60%) are employed or live in households in which someone is employed. Perhaps 3,000-5,000
of the uninsured are in some way associated with the university community and another
3,000-5,000 are unemployed, indigent and not eligible for any form of medical assistance.
A few broad observations about the uninsured in Ingham County can be made. The
uninsured includes very few children, women of childbearing age, and elderly, groups that
have good access to coverage through Medicaid, CHIP, and Medicare. Thus, most of the
uninsured are adults less than 65 years of age. In addition, the largest part of the
uninsured population appears to be women, many of whom are of middle age. Many of these
women are working in low-wage jobs, often part-time, that do not offer benefits. Other
uninsured women are not employed, but are dependents of a spouse working in a job that
does not offer benefits or does not offer benefits to dependents. Once again, these
characteristics are consistent with state and national patterns.
The Need for a Subsidized Health Insurance Program for Small Employers
Though IHP has had substantial initial success, it is important to remember that IHP is
a last resort, safety net program for persons who have no other way to obtain coverage. In
contrast, most non-elderly Americans, and most non-elderly Ingham County residents, are
covered by employer-sponsored health insurance. Further, the type of coverage provided by
employers is almost always broader and deeper than IHP coverage, which generally covers
only ambulatory services and otherwise has numerous limits and exclusions. There is no
question that an IHP member will have a higher degree of health security with
employer-sponsored coverage than he or she has today.
Our finding that 60% of IHP members are employed or live in a household in which someone is employed points up the fact that not all employers in Ingham County provide health insurance benefits to workers. Moreover, even if an employer does provide benefits, they may not be available to every worker (e.g., part-time workers may be excluded) or to dependents (e.g., only the workers themselves may be covered). For example, the County itself provides coverage to part-time employees, but does not contribute towards coverage for dependents of part-time workers.
The failure of some Ingham County employers to provide benefits to workers is part of a
well-known state and national pattern. Employers who do not provide benefits tend to be
small, service-industry firms that have low-wage work forces, often with extremely high
turnover rates. Many studies have shown that the principal barrier to the provision of
benefits is cost. It has also been demonstrated that if benefits can be made more
affordable, at least some of these employers will begin to provide coverage.
More specifically, it has been shown that limited subsidization of premiums for
employers that have not historically provided benefits can induce some such employers to
begin doing so. Based on this, the IHP board wishes to develop a program directed at small
Ingham County employers under which subsidies will be paid for the purpose of reducing
employer health insurance costs. IHP believes that this type of program can become an
important additional tool by which coverage can be expanded in Ingham County.
Size and Scale of a Subsidized Health Insurance Program for Small Employers
The type of program being contemplated by IHP will be limited in size and scale. This
is due mainly to the fact that the program will be offered only to firms that do not offer
benefits and have not done so for some time. As illustrated below, this requirement will
substantially limit the number of eligible firms and their associated
employees/dependents.
The 20,000-22,000 uninsured persons in Ingham County who are either employed or who
live in households in which some household member is employed consist of several major
subgroups that have quite different circumstances. We can quickly identify at least three
major subgroups:
· First, many uninsured persons are employed as full-time workers for employers who
simply do not provide benefits (or live in households in which some household member is
employed full-time for an employer who does not provide benefits).
· Second, a substantial number of uninsured persons are full-time workers (or
dependents of workers) in firms that offer benefits but require substantial premium
sharing by employees. These employees have opted not to participate in the firm's health
insurance program for reasons of affordability.
· Third, there are many part-time workers who work for firms that provide benefits
only to full-time workers, or perhaps, provide benefits to part-time workers but not their
dependents.
In both the second and third of these groups, the employer has established a health
insurance program that is providing coverage for at least some of its employees and
dependents, and will thus be ineligible for the IHP subsidy program. Only employers in the
first group will be eligible.
Therefore, if there are 21,000 uninsured persons in Ingham County who are employed (or
who live in households in which some household member is employed), it may be reasonable
to assume that half of these persons, or 10,500, are full-time workers or dependents of
full-time workers in firms that do not provide benefits. Further, it is probably
reasonable to assume that, of this number, only perhaps a quarter or a third are employed
by, or live in households in which someone is employed by, firms that can be induced
through a subsidy to offer health benefits. Based on this, it seems sensible to plan for a
subsidized insurance program with a membership of roughly 2,500-3,500. I believe that
these figures are a reliable estimate of likely program participation.
Membership Targets and Program Costs
Preliminary analyses have suggested that a subsidized insurance plan should revolve
around insurance products with a cost of roughly $120 per month per person. Such products
would provide comprehensive coverage coupled with aggressive cost control mechanisms. The
IHP subsidy would average $40 per month per person.
For planning purposes, it seems reasonable to assume a pattern of relatively slow
membership growth. This would be consistent with the experience in Wayne and Muskegon
Counties. Therefore, we assume the following:
| Year | Starting Members | Ending Members | Average Members | Member Months |
| FY 01 | 0 | 1,000 | 500 | 6,000 |
| FY 02 | 1,000 | 2,000 | 1,500 | 18,000 |
| FY 03 | 2,000 | 2,500 | 2,250 | 27,000 |
| FY 04 | 2,500 | 2,500 | 2,500 | 30,000 |
Making a set of further (minor) assumptions regarding inflation, costs of the program,
excluding IHP administrative expenses, are projected to be as follows:
| Year | Member Months | Cost per Month | Total Cost per Year |
| FY 01 | 6,000 | $40 | $240,000 |
| FY 02 | 18,000 | $42 | $756,000 |
| FY 03 | 27,000 | $44 | $1,188,000 |
| FY 04 | 30,000 | $46 | $1,380,000 |
IHP administrative expenses should be small, since most significant functions will be
left to the participating health plans. We will ignore these administrative expenses for
purposes of this analysis.
Program Funding
I propose that the IHP subsidized insurance program be funded partly out of existing
IHP resources and partly out of new resources. That is, I suggest that IHP budget certain
amounts from within its current revenues to provide partial support for the program. The
remainder would then come from new and additional DSH payments in which the non-federal
share would be supplied by the County; the federal match would be generated through the
usual set of transfers and Medicaid payments to our hospital partner(s).
More specifically, I propose that the County assume responsibility for contributing
about $1.05 million over a five year period, to participate in total operating expenses of
about $3.57 million. The Ingham Health Plan would contribute about $1.25 million from its
existing resources and the remaining $1.27 million will result from Federal participation
on the Ingham County contribution. I recommend that the County appropriate $150,000 in FY
2000, $150,000 in FY 2001, $250,000 in FY 2002, $250,000 in FY2003 and $250,000 in FY 2004
from the payments from Ingham Regional Medical Center to settle their contractual in-kind
services obligation to the County.
Over this same period the IHP would designate $1.25 million from its existing stream of
revenue (i.e., already-matched funds) to support the subsidized insurance plan, building
toward an enrollment of 2,500 persons by the end of FY2003.
The limit of 2,500 members for the implementation and funding plan can be easily
imposed by regulating enrollment.
It will be important to have a reasonably long-term commitment from the County in order
to make the program successful. Previous research has shown that employers will not
participate if they believe that the availability of the subsidy is not secure. Further,
the health plans on which IHP will depend to offer and operate subsidized products will
similarly not wish to begin selling a subsidized product unless they believe that the
subsidy will continue to be provided. Thus, a long-term funding commitment is critical to
making this program work.
Long Term Outlook for Expansion of Coverage in Ingham County
The proposed subsidized health insurance program for small employers should be seen as
one of a small number of major strategies to address the problem of the uninsured in
Ingham County. In fact, with implementation of this program, along with other initiatives
now under development at IHP, I believe that we are nearing the limit of what can be done
to deal with this problem in the absence of a broad-based state or national solution.
From the perspective of IHP, the County's approach should have three main components:
1) IHP views the basic IHP program as the minimum level of coverage which should be
available to any Ingham County resident for whom no alternative is available. By year-end,
the basic IHP program of coverage will have reached approximately 14,000 Ingham County
residents, or roughly half of the County's uninsured. Depending on the success of other
IHP initiatives, as listed below, some expansion of this program may be required over the
next several years.
2) IHP is working with Michigan State University to develop an approach to deal with
problems faced by uninsured persons associated with the university community. This group,
which we estimate to be in the range of 3,000-5,000, may require programs different from
those applicable to the rest of the County's uninsured. As presently contemplated, any
needed funding for this initiative will come from MSU and the usual matching sources. If
this can be accomplished, a large and particularly challenging part of the problem in
Ingham County will have been addressed. To the extent that IHP is successful in this area,
fewer individuals associated with the university will require coverage under the basic IHP
program.
3) The proposed subsidized health insurance program for small employers represents
IHP's main effort to directly address the largest group of the uninsured: those who are
employed but have no coverage. As discussed above, it may be possible to achieve a
membership of 2,500 persons through IHP's proposed program. It should be recognized,
however, that many small employers will not be willing to provide health insurance even if
a subsidy is available. Therefore, for employees of these firms, IHP's basic program will
be the only alternative. Similarly, for many part-time workers and dependents of workers
who are not eligible for coverage, IHP's basic program may be the only option.
Nevertheless, to the extent that any uninsured persons can be brought into
employer-sponsored health insurance arrangements, there will be less need for coverage
under the basic IHP program.
Taken together, these three approaches may bring us close to the practical limit of
what can be done at the local level. Short of a systematic state or national solution,
there will always be at least a few persons outside of the insurance system. If, between
these three approaches, we can reduce the number of such people in Ingham County to a few
thousand, we may conclude that we have accomplished all that it is possible to do.
Cc: IHP Board
Bruce Miller
Jay Rising
Jay Rosen
Introduced by the Human Services and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO APPROPRIATE FUNDS TO SUPPORT THE INGHAM HEALTH PLAN'S
SUBSIDIZED HEALTH INSURANCE PROGRAM FOR LOW WAGE PAYING FIRMS
WHEREAS, the Ingham County Board of Commissioners is committed to the goal of assuring
that all residents have access to an organized system of health care; and
WHEREAS, the Ingham Health Plan Corporation (IHP) has played an important role in the
County's efforts to provide such access to health care; and
WHEREAS, the IHP has implemented a health care benefit plan which currently provides
access to an organized system of health care to more than 11,000 previously uninsured
persons, and will increase enrollment in that plan to about 14,000 persons by January 1,
2001; and
WHEREAS, the IHP will implement during 2001 with Michigan State University programs to
address the needs of low income MSU students; and
WHEREAS, the IHP has implemented a Capital Area Prescription Program to provide low
income persons more than 60 years of age, who do not have insurance for prescription
drugs, and is working on plans to extend this discounted prescription drug purchasing
program to other residents of Ingham, Clinton and Eaton Counties; and
WHEREAS, the IHP believes that it is important to provide incentives to small business
to provide health insurance to workers and plans to implement a subsidized health
insurance program through local Health Management Organizations or Health Insurers for low
wage paying firms; and
WHEREAS, the IHP has requested the financial support of the Ingham County Board of
Commissioners to implement the subsidized health insurance program for up to 2,500 low
wage employees of small business in Ingham County; and
WHEREAS, the IHP plan to implement the subsidized health insurance program meets the
intent of the In-Kind Contract between Ingham Regional Medical Center and Ingham County
for the use of funds being paid to Ingham County under this agreement (to be used
primarily for public health programs); and
WHEREAS, Ingham Regional Medical Center and Ingham County have executed an In-Kind
Services Agreement whereby Ingham Regional contributes $794,022.16 annually to Ingham
County in services or cash through the year 2007, with the cash payments to be utilized by
the County primarily for public health purposes; and
WHEREAS, the Health Officer recommends that the Board of Commissioners designate $1.05 million from the cash payments made to Ingham County from Ingham Regional Medical Center to settle its in-kind obligation, for the purpose of supporting the implementation of the subsidized health insurance program to be implemented by the Ingham Health Plan Corporation during 2001, 2002, 2003 and 2004.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners appropriates
$1.05 million from reserved payments made by Ingham Regional Medical Center for use in a
subsidized health insurance program.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Board of Commissioners deems that this use will
satisfy the In-Kind Services Agreement condition that the funds be used primarily for
public health purposes which will partially satisfy the County's In-Kind Contract
obligation.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Controller is authorized to make periodic payments
from these funds to or on behalf of the Ingham Health Plan Corporation to support the
implementation of the subsidized health insurance program for low wage paying Ingham
County businesses.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Controller is authorized to transfer these funds to
the State of Michigan in order to contribute to Disproportionate Share Hospital payments
to Ingham Regional Medical Center and to the Sparrow Health System, given assurances that
these funds will be provided to the Ingham Health Plan Corporation, along with Federal
matching funds, in order to implement health benefit and health insurance coverage for low
income, uninsured residents of Ingham County.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Controller shall annually report to the Board of
Commissioners on the status of these funds and the IHP's subsidized health insurance
program.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Board Chairperson is authorized to sign a contract
with the Ingham Health Plan Corporation, after review by the County Attorney, setting out
the mechanisms and conditions of the relationship established in this resolution.
Return to top of document
MEMORANDUM
To: Human Services Committee
Finance Committee
From: Bruce Bragg
Date: November 16, 2000
Subject: Project Respect - Authorization to Contract
This is a recommendation to authorize an agreement with the City of Lansing to support
services directed at female students of Otto Middle School who have been identified as at
risk.
Statement of Purpose: The City of Lansing has contracted with the
Ingham County Health Department through the Otto Community Health Center to provide gender
specific services (Project RESPECT) for at-risk girls attending Otto Middle School. The
Ingham County Board of Commissioners initially authorized the Health Department to enter
into an agreement to provide this service back in 1997.
The Health Department is seeking authorization to extend this agreement with the City
of Lansing for an additional year beginning November 1, 2000 and ending October 31, 2001
for an amount of $12,700. These funds supplement County funds and other grant funds to
support services to the at-risk girls at Otto.
How This Fits the Bureau's Mission: One of the goals of the Department
is to prevent and control problems of particularly vulnerable population groups. Students,
especially girls, who experience problems in school are at risk of engaging in a variety
of activities that could get them in additional or more serious trouble with the law, with
the school, with the community or with their health and families. This proposal allows for
the ability to work with at-risk female students helping them to learn appropriate ways to
deal with conflict while developing good decision-making skills leading to healthier
behaviors.
Goals of Project: The project will continue to work with at-risk
females identified by school and health center personnel. The focus of this program is to
provide these girls with health services and information, a strong support system at
school, mentoring opportunities with women in the community and incentives to achieve
academically. The goals of this program are to improve school behavior, increase family
communication, improve problem-solving skills among peers, improve health well-being, and
increase awareness of various career and community opportunities.
Activities: Project RESPECT works with female students who are at risk
of being suspended from school because of inappropriate behavior. Students are referred
from school and health center staff and both child and parent(s) must agree to
participate. During the week, students participate in educational programming, group
support meetings, health education and mentoring activities. Students earn the privilege
to attend monthly field trips or participate in community service activities. Students can
also take part in a job shadowing experience throughout the summer months.
Outcome: The desired outcome will be to prevent and control problems of students, particularly females, who are at risk of being suspended from school, while at the same time help students learn skills necessary for leading a productive and healthy lifestyle. If the program prevents youth
from participating in activities that have the potential to get them into more trouble
and is successful in helping youth remain in the classroom, an important community
objective will be met.
I recommend that the Board of Commissioners adopt the attached resolution and authorize
the agreement with the City of Lansing.
Attachment
cc: Deb Brinson w/attachment
John Jacobs w/attachment
Introduced by the Human Services, and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO AMEND THE PROJECT RESPECT CONTRACT WITH THE CITY OF LANSING
WHEREAS, the City of Lansing is the recipient of a grant from the Michigan Family Independence Agency to implement a school suspension alternative program; and
WHEREAS, the City has subcontracted with Ingham County to implement Project Respect through the Otto Middle School Community Health Center, by supplementing already existing services provided by the County through the Community Health Center; and
WHEREAS, the Health Department has identified certain needs in the budget of the Otto
Community Health Center budget and the City has advised that funds are available to
enhance the operational budget to support such activities as: local field trips, mentoring
activities, program supplies and job shadowing activities; and
WHEREAS, the Health Officer has recommended that the Board of Commissioners authorize a
2000-2001 Project Respect agreement with the City of Lansing, and he has advised that the
expenditures and revenues are included in the adopted 2001 Health Department budget.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, the Ingham County Board of Commissioners authorizes a Project
Respect Agreement with the City of Lansing, an alternative program to school suspension,
for the period November 1, 2000 through October 30, 2001.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City of Lansing contribution to the agreement shall be
$12,700 to provide for such operational expenses as, local field trips, mentoring
activities, program supplies and job shadowing activities.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Board Chairperson is authorized to sign the agreement
after review by the County Attorney.
M E M O R A N D U M
To: Human Services Committee
Administrative Services/Personnel Committee
Finance Committee
From: Bruce Miller
Dean Sienko
Date: October 25, 2000
Subject: Recommendation to Authorize the Contract for Women's Health Physician Services
Earlier this year the Health Department issued a Request For Proposals for physician
services in the Women's Health Clinic. The Women's Health Clinic provides family planning
services to about 4,500 women each year and prenatal care to about 600 women a year. The
Clinic also provides Breast and Cervical Cancer Control Program (BCCCP) services to 850
women. Some of the women who come to the clinic for family planning, prenatal care and
BCCCP services require primary care for minor acute and other problems. The Clinic is
responsible for providing and/or arranging this care and other non OB-GYN specialty
services.
The last time there was competition for the Department's prenatal care business was
1984. The outcome of that process was the price for the service was reduced from about
$30,000 a year to zero. The Department did not expect such a dramatic reduction in price
with this competitive process, but was interested in seeing what a competitive process
might mean in terms of price and service.
The first step in soliciting proposals was the development of a Request for Proposals.
This was done in consultation with the Women's Health Coordinator and the County
Purchasing and Properties Department. The RFP was sent to the two vendors who had
expressed interest in bidding for the services and also published in the newspaper. Two
coverage proposals were received, one from Sparrow Health System and one from Ingham
Regional Medical Center (IRMC).
In considering how to evaluate the proposals, the Department invited two physicians
from outside the Department to participate in a review. The two were Dr. Ruth Hoppe from
Michigan State University and Dr. Oliver Hayes from Michigan State University. We met
three times with the two outside physicians and with Quess Derman, Women's Health Clinic
Coordinator. Dr. Hoppe and Dr. Hayes helped us define areas for further exploration and
were most helpful in identifying strengths and weaknesses of both proposals. Ms. Derman
helped explain the program to them and answered questions that came up during the review.
In coming up with a recommendation to the Board of Commissioners we considered the
views of Dr. Hoppe and Dr. Hayes, and those of Quess Derman. Both outside reviewers felt
that the two proposals had unique strengths and weaknesses and either was fundable. We
concurred that either proposal was fundable and would serve the interests of our patient
population. Each proposal had particular strengths. However, in the end we had to make a
decision, and we are recommending that the contract be awarded to Ingham Regional.
We are recommending a three year contract at $50,400 each year. Ingham Regional has
indicated that it will accept both the term of the contract and the amount.
There are several reasons we are recommending Ingham Regional's proposal. First, the
IRMC proposal was very professionally presented and offers a new and exciting way to serve
our patients.
Another reason we are recommending the proposal with IRMC is the providers in the
proposal consist of OB-GYN specialists. Women's Health is an OB-GYN unit. We believe at
this time it would be best staffed by OB-GYN physicians. Staffing the unit with OB-GYN
specialists will eliminate the need to transfer care of high risk women to a separate
OB-GYN service. Avoiding the transfer of these patients to another provider will improve
the continuity of care and help the Department provide supportive services to women who
needs extra help. Nurse practitioners in the unit believe they can learn a great deal from
OB-GYN providers and this knowledge will benefit patients in their care.
A third reason is the price of the IRMC proposal compared to the Sparrow proposal. The
price of the Sparrow proposal is $65,000. The price of Ingham Regional's proposal is
$50,400. Ingham is willing to accept this amount for three years. The three year savings
to the county will be at least $44,700.
We are recommending that the Board of Commissioners authorize the Health Department to
enter into a three year agreement with Ingham Regional Medical Center for physician
services in the Women's Health Unit.
cc: Bruce Bragg
Introduced by the Human Services, Administrative Services and Finance Committees of
the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION TO AUTHORIZE AN AGREEMENT WITH INGHAM REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER
FOR WOMEN'S HEALTH PHYSICIAN SERVICES
WHEREAS, the Health Department issued a Request For Proposals for physician services in
the Women's Health Clinic; and
WHEREAS, the Women's Health Clinic provides family planning services to about 4,500
women each year, prenatal care to about 600 women a year, Breast and Cervical Cancer
Program services to 850 women and the Clinic is responsible for providing and/or arranging
this care and other non- OB-GYN specialty services; and
WHEREAS, the Request for Proposals was developed in consultation with the Women's
Health Coordinator and the County Purchasing and Properties Department and sent to the two
vendors who had expressed interest in bidding for the services and also published in the
newspaper; and
WHEREAS, two coverage proposals were received, one from Sparrow Health System and one
from Ingham Regional Medical Center; and
WHEREAS, in considering how to evaluate the proposals, the Department invited two
physicians from outside the Department to participate in a review: Dr. Ruth Hoppe from
Michigan State University and Dr. Oliver Hayes from Michigan State University; and
WHEREAS, three meetings were held with the two outside physicians and with Quess
Derman, Women's Health Clinic Coordinator, Dean G. Sienko, MD, Health Department Medical
Director and Bruce Miller, MPH, Director of Community Services; and
WHEREAS, outside reviewers felt the two proposals had unique strengths and weaknesses
and either was fundable; and
WHEREAS, Dr. Sienko, Mr. Miller and Ms. Derman concurred either proposal was fundable
and would serve the interests of our patient population but in the end had to make a
recommendation; and
WHEREAS, Dr. Sienko, Mr. Miller and Ms. Derman are recommending a three year contract
be awarded to Ingham Regional in the amount of $50,400 each year; and
WHEREAS, Ingham Regional has indicated it will accept both the term of the contract and
the amount; and
WHEREAS, the reasons they are recommending Ingham Regional's proposal are as follows:
1) the IRMC proposal was very professionally developed and presented; 2) the IRMC
providers are OB-GYN specialists and Women's Health is an OB-GYN unit; 3) staffing the
unit with OB-GYN specialists will eliminate the need to transfer care of high risk women
to a separate OB-GYN service; 4) avoiding the transfer of care will improve continuity of
care and help the Department provide supportive services to women who need extra help; and
WHEREAS, the difference in price of the IRMC proposal will result in a three year
savings to the county of at least $44,700.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Health Department is authorized to enter into a
three year contract with Ingham Regional Medical Center for physician services in Women's
Health.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that services shall include: 1) 20 hours of physician coverage
for clinics held at Women's Health Services; 2) physician back-up for prenatal care
services provided by nurse practitioners in centers other than Women's Health Services to
include physician visits, chart review, and labor and delivery services for prenatal
patients of the Ingham Community Health Centers in Leslie, Stockbridge, Saint Lawrence,
and Willow Plaza Adolescent Health Center; 3) labor and delivery for all ICHD prenatal
patients; 4) 24 hour/365 day after hours call and hospital services for all ICHD OB-GYN
patients; 5) After hours call and hospital services for primary care patients of the
Women's Health Center; 6) Consultation, chart review and educational support for the nurse
practitioners of the Women's Health Center; 7) four hours per week of physician time to
serve as the on-site Medical Director for Women's Health Services; 8) a designated
physician who serves as medical director for the Health Department in the absence of the
Department's Medical Director.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the annual payment will be $50,400 a year for three years
starting January 1, 2001 through December 31, 2003.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Board Chairperson is authorized to sign the Women's
Health Physician Services Agreement after review by the County Attorney.
M E M O R A N D U M
TO: Finance and Liaison Committees
FROM: Darnell Earley, Deputy Controller for
Administrative Services and Budget
RE: Third Quarter 2000 Budget
Adjustments, Year End Adjustment, and Contingency Fund Update
DATE: November 8, 2000
______________________________________________________________________________
Enclosed please find the recommended adjustments to the Ingham County budget for the
third quarter of fiscal year 2000. The total decrease to the General Fund is $11,307.
The quarterly budget amendment process as authorized by the Board of Commissioners is
necessary to make adjustments to the adopted budget. Generally, adjustments are made as a
result of updated revenue and expenditure projections, fund transfers, reappropriation,
accounting and contractual changes, errors, and omissions.
This resolution also authorizes the County Controller, as part of the year end budgeting process, to make any necessary transfers among all budgeted funds, activities, and line items in order to comply with Public Act 621 (Uniform Budgeting & Accounting Act), and to balance the 2000 Budget. The General Fund budget will be adjusted to the amount of $61,536,166 for the fourth quarter of 2000.
Also included is an update of contingency fund spending so far this year. The current
contingency amount is $307,110. The attached document details how the Board has allocated
the contingency funds throughout the year, beginning with a balance of $600,000.
Should you require any additional information or have questions regarding this process,
please don't hesitate to contact me.
cc Gerald W. Ambrose
Introduced by the Administrative Services/Personnel, Human Services, Law and Courts,
and Finance Committees of the:
INGHAM COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING ADJUSTMENTS TO THE 2000 INGHAM COUNTY BUDGET AND
AUTHORIZING THE CONTROLLER TO MAKE YEAR END BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners adopted the 2000 Budget on October 26, 1999 and has
authorized certain amendments since that time, and it is now necessary to make some
adjustments as a result of updated revenue and expenditure projections, fund transfers,
reappropriations, accounting and contractual changes, errors and omissions, and additional
appropriation needs; and
WHEREAS, the Liaison Committees and the Finance Committee have reviewed the proposed
budget adjustments prepared by the Controller's staff and have made adjustments where
necessary; and
WHEREAS, Public Act 621 of 1978 requires that local units of government maintain a
balanced budget and periodically adjust the budget to reflect revised revenue and
expenditure levels; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners annually authorizes the Controller to make
necessary year end transfers to comply with state statute.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ingham County Board of Commissioners hereby directs
the Controller to make the necessary transfers to adjust revenues and expenditures in the
following funds, according to the attached schedules:
2000 BUDGET PROPOSED PROPOSED
FUND DESCRIPTION 11/01/00 CHANGES BUDGET
101* General Fund $61,444,473 ($11,307) $61,433,166
208 Parks 1,340,372 (24,100) 1,316,272
266 Anti-Drug Abuse Grant 345,132 0 345,132
267 Community Corrections 1,091,049 4,000 1,095,049
298 P/A Cooperative Reimb. Grant 617,318 8,000 625,318
508 Parks Enterprise 194,268 0 194,268
664 Mach. & Equip. Revolving 458,242 39,220 497,462
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the first year's debt service payment on the Consolidated
Courts Facility, totaling $284,591, will be paid from the interest earnings on the $6
million set aside from the proceeds from the sale of Ingham Medical Center to build the
facility.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that at the end of 2000, up to $100,000 of any revenues
exceeding expenses in the general fund, if available, shall be reserved for moving
expenses related to the new Consolidated Courts Facility.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that of the $800,000 approved in the 2000 Budget to be transferred from the inmate telephone fund balance to the public improvements fund, $400,000 of this shall instead be transferred to the Consolidated Courts Facility construct